A proposed McDonald’s outlet in Balgowlah has been formally rejected following concerns from residents, planners, and NSW Police over traffic, amenity, and antisocial behaviour.
Background and Application History
In February 2025, McDonald’s submitted a $4 million development application (DA2025/0132) for a new restaurant at 37 Roseberry Street, Balgowlah. The plan included a drive-through, parking for 41 vehicles, and round-the-clock trading. Following widespread community objections, the proposed hours were amended to 5 a.m. to midnight, seven days a week. Despite the changes, the application was escalated to the Northern Beaches Local Planning Panel for determination.
Explanatory Details and Rejection Grounds
On 2 July 2025, the panel unanimously refused the application. Panel members cited unresolved concerns around traffic congestion, particularly given the site’s proximity to the Manly Vale B-Line stop and its location near residential areas. Police had previously raised concerns about public safety. They referenced 112 incidents recorded within the vicinity over the past two years. A comparable 24-hour McDonald’s nearby recorded 58 incidents in the same period.
The panel noted that the applicant failed to adequately demonstrate that the development would not cause unreasonable impacts to the surrounding road network or contribute to further antisocial behaviour.
Community Sentiment and Local Opposition
Residents submitted 740 formal responses during the consultation period. There were only two supporting the proposal. A Facebook group formed to mobilise opposition gathered over 400 members, and an online petition against the development attracted close to 4,000 signatures. Community concerns included road safety for pedestrians, increased vehicle movements, noise, odour, and the site’s interface with nearby homes and schools.
McDonald’s Response and Future Actions
McDonald’s has not confirmed whether it will seek a review or appeal the panel’s decision. A company spokesperson stated that they are reviewing the outcome and considering their next steps.
Published 12-July-2025
